2/23/05
THIS IS ONE OF THOSE MORNING EMAILS THAT EVENTUALLY TURNS INTO A SORTOF STORY.............
NOBODY WRITES IN HEAVEN
Cat wakes me up with a jolt early this morning by leaping on my chest. After I feed her, I notice that she has spread some little diarrhea driblets on the bed. This is a first for her----she's never malfunctioned before. In my unpleasantly awake, unguarded, state, I have a sudden depressing vision of college classmate Scott Turow's industry and brains and enterprise----grinding out more million dollar novels, energetically pursuing his law career, having the requisite haute-bourgeois wife and kids and big house on the North Shore... As in, "What would Scott Turow be doing this morning?" And: "What was Scott Turow doing at 19 when you were moldering in Nam? He was already meeting with publishers and planning & laying the cornerstones of his career, THAT’s what he was doing." Like the voice of a dim, nagging, mom.
Of course, my own living mother has forgotten, in her Alzheimer’s ward, all that bullshit, is very sweet and giggly and quite beyond ambition, society, achievement, & time. But the mother introject (or some other nagging voice, maybe the voice of my own thwarted ambition or self loathing) continues to haunt me.
I suppose it's small consolation to reflect that, though I respect his craft and prose and experience and civility and talent and work ethic, I've never been able to get through any of Turow's novels. I mean, I’ve finished them, but only by skipping big chunks in the middle. (If you PAID me to read every word I'd probably more or less like 'em. Or maybe just wonder who the hell the writer is speaking to. Presumably everybody but me.) Nor could I bear being a Chicago D.A. or whatever he is or was (though I would kill to see that slice of society, get that people-watching experience).
Heck, I could depress myself the same way thinking about any gogetter. (If I were George Bush, I'd be having my super summarized briefing be read to me this morning, my lies of the day prepared by Karl Rove, my decisions made by Dick Cheney, I'd be attending the morning White House Bible study class, I'd be thinking of more ways to subvert the Constitution to advance the agenda of greedy corporations, I'd be working out for two hours, dispensing fatherly advice to Jenna & Barbara: "Don't drink and drug like I did, not that I ever did. And get your orifices checked daily for STD's, not that you, or I, have orifices...", I'd be thinking about all the mistakes I never made in my life, I'd be letting others do my bleeding & suffering for me, I'd be making more plans to take from the poor and give to the rich.... Jesus. It sounds like W is in hell on Earth! Yet he's under the impression he's enjoying himself.) One man's hell is another man's heaven.
Hell is other people. --Sartre
Nothing's either good or bad but thinking makes it so. --Hamlet.
The mind is its own master, and can make a heaven of hell, a hell of heaven. --Milton's Satan.
It's mind over matter. I don't mind and you don't matter. ---My DI in basic training.
Is it slightly consoling to consider the life of recent-self-shooter Hunter Thompson, who at least wrote some stuff which actually meant something to me? And who clearly never tamed his demons and was often possessed and finally taken down by them? But Hunter must have had some good times, plinking gongs in his "compound" with his high powered rifles (and fantasizing turning them on himself?) even as he watched, with disgust, his beloved Aspen turn into a private reserve for piggies.
If I were Sam Shepard (the playwright, not the 1950’s wife-murderer) I'd be galloping my horse about my Virginia estate, I'd be savoring the memories of all the beautiful actresses I've fucked, I'd be planning my latest surrealist epic, I'd be congratulating myself for the beautiful children I had with Jessica Lange (I did have some, didn't I?), I'd be considering which juicy movie part to accept (the intriguing Bulgarian-French artsy-fartsy production to be shot in Herzogovenia? Or the cameo in the upcoming James Cameron blockbuster?) Or maybe I'd be on a set in Arizona, evading prying phone calls from Jessica, who's heard I'm banging the ingenue. (Am I still married to Jessica? Does she still care whether I'm straying?)
Of course, if I were Arthur Miller, I'd be in heaven, trading notes with Eugene O'Neill and Ibsen and Strindberg (ooops, no, he's in hell, he wouldn't be comfortable in heaven, heaven would BE a kind of hell for him, even if God had sent him to heaven he would have undoubtedly opted for hell as a lesser hell than heaven) and Shakespeare and Moliere and, yes, even Sophocles. Would Tennessee Williams be there? Or would he be in a separate quarter of heaven, rather like the French Quarter, stocked with juicy young gonorrhea-free hustlers? And when all the playwrights got together, would there be some pissing contests? Would everybody STILL be just a tad jealous of The Bard? Would Christopher Marlowe be blowing it out his ass about how many more plays he could have written had he not been skewered in a sword fight at age 29? Would Keats toddle in from the Poets’ Corner, saying: "If only I HAD lived to 29, what I would have written!"
And over in the musicians' quarter (do the various disciplines mingle in heaven? or are they carefully segregated for their own protection?) are Mozart and Mendelssohn and Gershwin bragging about the brilliant shit they would have written had they lived into their 40's? And Keats, overhearing them: "Listen to 'em, talking about 40! When I had ceased to be before I even hit 30!" "Aww, go back to the poets' crib," says John Lennon. "How'd you like to be me? ---Struck down by an assassin's bullet with 3 lp's still in my head, crying to get out?"
Keats retreats, and runs into Sylvia Plath. "At least you made it to 30," he says, and she slaps him, hard. "What's more, you had the choice of living on. I was struck down by the white plague, which so exhausted me that my last two years were like a posthumous life."
She slaps him again and says, "You know NOTHING about depression."
"Read me again," he replies. Could the man who wrote: "....then on the shore/Of the wide world I stand alone and think/Till love and fame to nothingness do sink," have known nothing of depression?"
"Well, you weren't so depressed you committed suicide, so how depressed could you have been?"
"Not only was I dying young, but I knew, and here I quote myself, 'the world is full of misery and heartbreak, pain, sickness, and oppression.'"
"Who hasn't considered making his quietus with a bare bodkin?" says The Bard, who has been eavesdropping on them. "But that the dread of something after death,/The undiscovered country from whose bourn/No traveller returns, puzzles the will/And makes us rather bear those ills we have/Than fly to others we know not of?"
"Well it didn't puzzle MY will!" says Plath, I just stuck my head in the oven! "It didn't puzzle my will either!" cheerfully chimes in Hemingway, toting a shotgun but still missing half his head. "Nor mine neither!" says Hunter Thompson, still bleeding a tad from his recent self-inflicted mouthshot. "Well, it puzzled my will for 67 years. Plus, I self-medicated and that might've gotten me through some rough spots. And for a long time I managed to turn my firearms on other things beside myself. But by and by my body broke down, plus I wasn't writing like I used to...."
"That's a killer combo. And add to that having suicide and bipolarism run in your family!" says Poppa Hem.
"Is bipolarism a word?" says Hunter.
"No, it's not," says Joe Heller. "And death runs in everybody's family. So that's no excuse. Look at me: I got a horrible wasting disease. But did I give up on life? Hell no! I went on to write several more books."
"But were they GOOD books?" says Hemingway.
"No, they weren't," says Heller. "But they paid some bills."
"Do Jews have a prohibition against suicide? Jews don't seem to kill themselves very often," says Hemingway.
"That sounds vaguely anti-Semitic, Poppa," says Heller. "Anyway, Catholics have a big prohibition against suicide but that didn't seem to slow you or your uncle or your granddaughter down. But since you asked: the reason Jews DON'T kill themselves more often is because we have learned to enjoy suffering. Plus, we're hoping to outlive the competition."
Tennessee Williams, attracted by the hubbub, ambles over from the gay ghetto. "I hear you killed yourself, too," says Hem. "Welcome to the club."
"Not really. I choked on an inhaler…and my own puke. I mean, I might as well have killed myself. I did enough drugs and booze to kill myself. But you know what? I kept waking up and going to the typewriter, morning after morning, grinding out the plays...."
"....And they all sucked. The only decent writing you did in your last two decades was your memoir," says Hunter Thompson.
"...That's what they said about me, too," says Hem.
"What the hell do THEY know?" says Tennessee. "If I had listened to THEM I would have stopped writing at 25."
"25!" says Keats. "If only I COULD have written at 25."
"You didn't die until you were 26," reminds Williams.
"Yes, but I was so blasted by the White Plague the last two years were a write off," says Keats. "Why, I had written more and better stuff, by age 24, than did Chaucer, Shakespeare, OR Milton. Can you imagine the moves I woulda busted had I lived to 45?!" Just then, attracted by the hubbub, Chaucer and Milton saunter over and are joined by HNG's (Heavenly New Guys), Arthur Miller & Spalding Gray.
"So, I'll bet you guys have written some unbelievably fantastic stuff since you've been here," Miller asks them.
"Nobody writes in heaven, newbie," says Chaucer.
"We're too busy getting laid," says Shakespeare.
"Or getting awards," adds Ibsen.
"Or just getting used to SEEING again," says Milton, blinking brightly. "I'm STILL not quite used to it."
"If it's writing you want," says Franz Kafka, "you're better off in hell. That's where I'm going as soon as I get my paperwork processed."
"Is there a hold up?" asks Miller.
"There's ALWAYS a hold up. God is a very busy guy. I've been petitioning him for decades. So far the best I've managed is an appointment with his assistant secretary, Albert Schweitzer, but even that keeps getting postponed. Meanwhile, I live in hope."
"Hope?" asks Miller.
"Hope of some day getting to hell and writing again."
"I know what you mean," says Miller. "I wrote a couple good things in my youth, then spent 50 years coming up dry. But I never stopped trying."
"Oh, so you've already SPENT some time in hell," says Kafka.
"No, that happened on Earth," says Miller.
"50 years coming up dry, and yet you didn't kill yourself?" chorus Hemingway, Plath, and Thompson.
"Well," says Miller, "I'm Jewish, too."
"I was writing pretty well right up to time I killed myself," says Spalding Gray.
"Lemme guess," says Kafka. "You're not Jewish."
"And I probably could have written a fantastic piece about my suicide."
"He's not kidding," says Miller. "His performance pieces, while a bit narcissistic for my earnest tastes, were nonetheless excellent."
"You could write a piece up here," suggests Thompson. "Maybe I could, too."
"Nobody wants to hear about suicide. Not in HEAVEN," says Hemingway. "You're lucky they even let you in. In the old days they didn't. I tried writing something about my suicide and it just about made me want to kill myself. Plus, I couldn't get it published."
"Suicide is frowned upon up here," says Plath. "God wouldn't publish my posthumous suicide poems, either. He keeps saying: 'Write about LIFE, Sylvia, LIFE."
"God talks to you?" says Kafka.
"Sure. He drops in on the writers' commissary all the time."
"I never see him there."
"You have to get up very very early to catch God," says Plath.
"I'm too depressed to get up early," says Kafka.
"So? See what you're missing?"
"But I thought you were depressed, too. Suicidally depressed."
"Oh I am, I am," says Plath. "But I'm not so depressed I lie in bed whinging about it! Any writer worth her salt can at least jump out of bed, the earlier the better, write some final despairing poems, and then kill herself before the kids wake up. But what would you know? You're so self involved you never had kids."
"Well you're so self-involved you killed yourself even though you DID have kids."
“Well you’re so self-involved you never even married your fiancé…….just dryhumped her with despairing epistles….”
"Well you're so self-involved your husband left you."
"Well you're so self-involved you barely got published in your lifetime. Plus, on your deathbed, you told your best friend Max Brod to burn your unpublished works.”
“Well you’re so self-involved you heedlessly created a posthumous suicide cult of young women fans---an unintended consequence of your self-absorbed self-destruction. Or WAS it unintended?”
Plath just gives Kafka her best Cheshire cat smile. “Well you’re so self-involved you continue to fruitlessly petition God to send you to hell rather than actually doing something constructive or creative.”
“Well I haven’t noticed YOU writing anything lately, or since you got here, for that matter.”
“And why are your EIGHTY years of writer’s block better than my FORTY years of writer’s block?”
Both Plath and Kafka, shamed and shocked and exhilarated by their own vituperation, their stock of insults depleted, fall silent. In fact, the assembled host of genius writers ALL fall silent. They're all listening, listening for their muse. And they hear nothing. That's the way it is in heaven. That's the way it's always been and that's the way it's always going to be. They walk over, en masse, to the train station, the station with the tracks leading down to hell. They stand hopefully on the platform, looking down the tracks, waiting for a train. Either one arriving or one departing would do fine. Because what comes up must inevitably go back down. They do this every day. And every day they see nothing. Every day they are disappointed and cast down and know they must remain in heaven, which is hell for writers.
Oh, and my cat? She's been sitting on my leg the whole time I've been writing this. And yes, she's left cat poop spots all over my sweatpants.
---FIN---